Quick answer
Beeswax, soy and coconut each have a strength, and none wins on every count. Beeswax melts hottest, with its own honey scent and the highest price. Soy is a firm plant wax that carries fragrance well and burns with little soot. Coconut wax is soft, smooth and easy to scent, but it is nearly always a blend, sometimes with paraffin. A well-made candle and a trimmed wick matter more than the wax.
Beeswax, soy and coconut are the three waxes you'll often see on candles sold as natural. One comes from a hive, the other two from soybeans and coconuts, and where each starts explains most of how it behaves in a candle and why the prices differ.
Our own candles are 100% soy wax, and we get to why near the end. If you're weighing beeswax vs soy, or wondering where coconut wax fits, start with where each one comes from.
Where Each Wax Comes From
Beeswax is the oldest of the three. Worker honeybees make it in glands on their abdomens and build their comb from it, and beekeepers collect it alongside the honey. Of the three, it's the one that comes out of nature already a wax. Candle beeswax is filtered, and sometimes lightened to white, but not otherwise changed, which is why it keeps a faint honey smell and a natural gold color.
Soy wax is soybean oil that has been hydrogenated, a process that adds hydrogen to the oil's fats until they stay solid at room temperature. It came into candles in the late 1990s as a plant-based alternative to paraffin.
Coconut wax starts as coconut oil, which melts at about 75°F, so a warm kitchen turns it liquid. Hydrogenation raises that only to roughly 97 to 104°F, still too soft to hold a candle together on its own. That's why coconut wax for candles is nearly always a blend: coconut with soy, with apricot wax, with beeswax, or with paraffin.
Break for research
Help us figure out our next scents
These scents are top of nose right now. Give us your opinion by January 9.
- Cashmere plumSmells like: ripe plum over soft woods
- Himalayan bambooSmells like: fresh-cut green stems
- PetrichorSmells like: the first rain on warm ground
- Coriander and limeSmells like: lime zest with a peaty, smoky edge
Want to hear which ones make it?
We'll email you the results and which scents go into testing.
Thanks!
You're on the list. Check your inbox.
There was an error. Please refresh the page and try again.
Unsubscribe anytime. Your vote counts whether or not you sign up.
Beeswax vs Soy vs Coconut Wax at a Glance
The table puts the three side by side on what you'll notice at home.
| Wax | Comes from | Melts at | Scent | On top | Worth knowing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beeswax | Honeybees, collected with the honey harvest | 144 to 147°F | Its own light honey note; often sold unscented | Firm and smooth, natural gold | Highest melting point and highest price |
| Soy | Soybean oil, hydrogenated until solid | 113 to 129°F | Carries added fragrance well | Can frost with white crystal patterns | Firm enough to use at 100% in a container |
| Coconut | Coconut oil, hydrogenated, then blended | About 97 to 109°F on its own, by supplier | Known for an easy, strong scent throw | Soft, smooth and creamy | Nearly always a blend; some include paraffin |
If you want a scented candle, soy and coconut pull ahead of beeswax. If you want a taper or pillar that holds its shape, beeswax's higher melting point is the reason to choose it. If you want the science of what happens in the flame, our guide to how candles work walks through it.
Beeswax: Golden, Firm and Costly for a Reason
Beeswax's high melting point is its biggest strength. It takes more heat to melt, so a beeswax candle holds its shape, which is why it has long been the wax for tapers, pillars and church candles.
The trade-offs come from the same places. Bees use a lot of honey to make wax, and one long-standing estimate puts it at 6.7 to 8.8 pounds of honey for every pound of wax, so the supply is small and the price is high. Its own honey note is part of the appeal, and many beeswax candles are sold unscented for that reason. It's also an animal product, which matters in a vegan home.
One claim is worth setting aside: that beeswax candles purify the air by releasing negative ions. We couldn't find good evidence for it. A candle burns fuel; it doesn't filter a room. What the testing does support is simpler, and still a point in beeswax's favor: in a 2002 study, formaldehyde from beeswax candles was similar to or slightly above background levels.
Soy Wax: Firm, Plant-Based and Easy to Scent
Soy is what most people mean today by a plant wax. It's firm enough to hold its shape in a container, it melts at a lower temperature than beeswax, and it carries added fragrance well, which is why so many scented candles are poured with it. In a 2002 study, soy wax candles produced little or no soot, and their formaldehyde was similar to or slightly above background levels, about the same as beeswax.
Its quirk is frosting: white, crystal-like patterns on the top and sides as the wax slowly re-crystallizes after it cools. It's cosmetic and doesn't change how the candle burns. On our candles we leave it be: a slightly imperfect, natural burn is better than a chemically perfect one.
For how soy compares with petroleum wax, our soy wax vs paraffin guide goes deeper, and our guide to what goes into a soy candle covers the ingredients.
Coconut Wax: Read the Blend
Coconut wax has the best reputation of the three for scent throw and a smooth, creamy top, and both are real advantages. The catch is the name. Because coconut oil is too soft to stand alone, a candle labeled coconut wax is almost always a blend, and a label may not say what it's blended with.
Apricot coconut wax, a popular blend for container candles, is a good example. It's creamy and soft, and one supplier's version lists apricot, coconut, soy and paraffin among its ingredients, and credits the paraffin for much of its strong scent throw. Other coconut blends lean on soy or beeswax instead. None of that makes a coconut candle a bad one. It means the word coconut on the front tells you less than the wax list on the back, so if paraffin matters to you, look for a candle that names its full blend.
Which Candle Wax Burns Cleanest?
The wax matters less here than most labels suggest. The National Candle Association puts it plainly: all candle waxes burn cleanly when the candle is well made, and there is no such thing as a soot-free wax. Soot depends mainly on wick length and a disturbed flame, more than on the type of wax.
The 2002 study lines up with that for the natural waxes: soy burned with little or no soot, and formaldehyde from soy and beeswax was similar to or slightly above background levels. In a real room, the difference usually comes down to habits: trim the wick to about a quarter inch, keep the candle out of drafts, and give the first burn time to melt across the top. Our guide to burning a candle properly has the rest, and clean-burning candles covers what else to look for, from the wick to the fragrance.
How to Choose
Start from what you want the candle to do.
| If you want | Look at |
|---|---|
| A taper or pillar, with no added scent | Beeswax |
| A scented candle that is plant-based and firm | Soy |
| The smoothest top and the easiest scent throw | A coconut blend that lists its full wax blend |
| No animal products | Soy, or a coconut blend without beeswax |
| No paraffin | 100% beeswax or 100% soy; check any blend before you buy |
Whatever you pick, the label is worth a second look. "Soy blend" and "coconut wax" both describe blends, and a candle called pure soy isn't always 100% soy, so look for a percentage. Our non-toxic candle checklist covers the rest of what to read on a label.
Why We Chose 100% Soy
We chose soy because it holds its shape in a container and burns with less soot than paraffin. It also carries our phthalate-free fragrance oils well, at a load we set per scent so the aroma stays subtle yet present. The candles use natural wood wicks and are poured in recyclable aluminum.
The trade-offs are the ones above. Soy frosts, so no two of our candles look exactly alike on top, and it doesn't have the honey glow people love in beeswax. Each candle drops into a reusable wood container, so you can swap scents whenever you like and recycle the aluminum when it's finished. The Sero Candle page has every scent, and our ingredients page lists what goes in and what we leave out.
The Short Version
Beeswax melts hottest, smells faintly of honey and costs the most. Soy is firm, plant-based and easy to scent, with a frosted top that's purely cosmetic. Coconut wax gives the smoothest top and an easy scent throw, but it's nearly always a blend, so read what it's blended with. All three can burn cleanly; a well-made candle and a trimmed wick matter more than the wax.
Sources
- Rezaei, Wang and Johnson, "Combustion characteristics of candles made from hydrogenated soybean oil," Journal of the American Oil Chemists' Society, 2002
- National Candle Association, "Elements of a Candle: Wax"
- Wikipedia, "Beeswax" (melting point; honey consumed per pound of wax, after Whitcomb, 1946)
- Wikipedia, "Coconut oil" (melting points of coconut oil and hydrogenated coconut oil)
- A candle-supply listing for coconut wax (melting point and use in blends)
- A candle-supply listing for coconut apricot wax (listed ingredients)
Common Questions About Beeswax, Soy and Coconut Wax
Which is better, beeswax or soy candles?
It depends on what you want from the candle. Beeswax melts at a higher temperature and holds its shape, and it carries its own light honey scent, which is why many beeswax candles are sold unscented. Soy is plant-based, firm enough for a container and carries added fragrance well. In a 2002 study, formaldehyde from both was similar to or slightly above background levels.
Is coconut wax better than soy wax?
Coconut wax is known for a smooth, creamy top and an easy scent throw, which are real advantages. It is too soft to use on its own, though, so a coconut wax candle is almost always a blend, often with soy, apricot or beeswax and sometimes with paraffin. Soy can be used at 100%. If you prefer coconut, look for a candle that lists its full wax blend.
What is apricot coconut wax?
Apricot coconut wax is a soft, creamy container wax made by blending coconut with apricot wax, usually with other waxes mixed in to firm it up. One supplier's version lists apricot, coconut, soy and paraffin among its ingredients. It is popular for its smooth finish and scent throw, but it is a blend, not a single natural wax.
Do beeswax candles purify the air?
We could not find good evidence that they do. The claim usually rests on beeswax releasing negative ions, and no study we found shows beeswax doing that more than other waxes. A candle burns fuel; it does not filter a room. What a 2002 study did find is that formaldehyde from beeswax candles was similar to or slightly above background levels.
Which candle wax burns the cleanest?
No wax is soot-free, and the National Candle Association says all candle waxes burn cleanly when the candle is well made. In a 2002 study, soy candles produced little or no soot, and formaldehyde from soy and beeswax was similar to or slightly above background levels. In practice, a trimmed wick, a steady flame away from drafts and a first burn that melts edge to edge matter more than the wax.
Why are beeswax candles more expensive?
Bees use a lot of honey to make wax. One long-standing estimate puts it at 6.7 to 8.8 pounds of honey for every pound of beeswax, so the supply is small next to plant waxes made from soybean or coconut oil. Beekeepers collect it alongside the honey harvest, and a hive only makes so much in a season.
